Thrive Causemetics Mascara Review: Is It Really Worth It?!

If you’re like me and have sensitive eyes, you know the struggle of finding a mascara that doesn’t leave you rubbing them raw by the end of the day. Enter: Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara.

I’ll admit, I had high hopes but was skeptical—especially since it’s a tubing mascara formula, which I usually associate with weird flaking or lackluster results. But after using it religiously for months, I can confidently say: this stuff lives up to the hype.

Let’s break it all down—the good, the bad, and whether it’s really worth adding to your makeup bag.

First Things First: Why I Made the Switch

For over a decade, I was a Clinique mascara devotee. It was my go-to, my holy grail—until (I think) they changed the formula, and suddenly, my sensitive eyes were constantly irritated. The hunt for a replacement was exhausting. I tried traditional mascaras, fiber mascaras, and even waterproof mascaras—nothing worked.

Then one of my closest friends reccomended Thrive Causemetics Mascara and after seeing rave reviews on their site, I had to try it. It claimed to be a best-selling tubing mascara with flake-free tubing technology, dramatic length, and a false lash effect—all while being a “clean” beauty product. (Side note: I take “clean” beauty claims with a grain of salt, but if a product is high-performance and doesn’t irritate my eyes, I don’t care what marketing terms they slap on it.)

The Formula: What Makes It Different?

Unlike usual mascaras, Thrive Causemetics’ tubing formula wraps around each individual lash instead of just coating them in pigment. This makes for a smudge-proof, flake-free experience that lasts all day long—even in humid weather.

Some key ingredients include:

• Orchid Stem Cell Complex – Claims to support lash growth and lash health.

• Castor Oil – A longtime beauty hack for healthier-looking lashes (and brows!).

• Shea Butter & Panthenol – Conditions natural lashes to keep them soft and flexible.

And unlike some traditional mascaras, this one is synthetic fragrance-free, so if you’re sensitive to scents, you’re in luck.

Left eye: with Thrive Mascara | Right Eye: Without Thrive Mascara

Application: How to Get the Best Results

I’ll be honest—the first time I used this, I applied way too much product and ended up with clumpy lashes. The key things to remember:

• Start at the base of your lashes and wiggle the mascara wand upward.

• Use thin layers—this formula is buildable, but if you rush, it can get messy.

• Let the first coat dry slightly before adding a second coat (and third if you want!) for maximum length and volume.

Pro tip: If you have straight lashes, use an eyelash curler first for better results. This formula holds a curl well without feeling stiff or crunchy.

Shop my other Makeup Favorites

The Best Part? The Removal Process

Here’s where this mascara really won me over: it comes off effortlessly with warm water.

No scrubbing, no raccoon eyes, no harsh makeup removers needed. The tubing formula literally slides off in pieces, leaving your lash health intact.

I’ve always hated removing waterproof mascara (seriously, why is it so stubborn?), so the fact that this high-performance formula stays put all day but rinses off with just water is a game-changer.

My Only Gripe…

The only gripe I have is that you can only buy it from the Thrive Causemetics website—which is kind of annoying. However, they often run sales and have a free shipping offer if you sign up for emails, so it’s not too bad.

Also, their packaging is deep blue/turquiose, which makes it easy to spot in my makeup bag (a small but satisfying perk).

Left eye: with Thrive Mascara | Right Eye: Without Thrive Mascara

Final Verdict: Is It Worth It?

YES. Thrive Causemetics Mascara is officially my new holy grail. It gives me the look of lash extensions, show-stopping lashes, and stays put all day without irritating my sensitive eyes. It’s got the high-performance formula of a fiber mascara but with the removal ease of a tubing mascara.

Would I recommend it? Absolutely. Whether you’re looking for better results than your usual mascaras, or just want something that makes your eyes pop without the hassle of false eyelashes, this mascara does a fantastic job.

If you’re ready to give it a shot, check it out on the Thrive Causemetics website—and keep an eye out for their free shipping offer!

Would love to hear your thoughts—have you tried this? Do you love it as much as I do? Drop your thoughts in the comments!

This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase something using my links, I may earn a small commission at no cost to you.

---

You might also like…